214-636-8100

mj@dallascpa.net
MJ Ahmed CPA PLLC

From Moonshine Redux to Modern Cigarettes: Indiana's Tax Dilemma

The recent upsurge in Indiana’s cigarette taxes isn’t just a fiscal strategy but a resurgence of bygone smuggling days. With state-wide hikes in per-pack prices, lawmakers are instituting stringent penalties to halt smugglers, reminiscent of the 1930s Prohibition busts on moonshiners.

Rewinding to the '30s, we find familiar tales of operations against illicit alcohol and tobacco networks. Today, the narrative shifts from hidden stills to interstate highways and shopping centers, where thrifty smokers bypass taxes by journeying to states with lower expenses or purchasing in bulk. Image 1

States like Kentucky and Tennessee serve as cautionary examples. Kentucky’s minimal cigarette tax—a mere 10 cents per pack versus Indiana’s $1—has made it a hotspot for exports, with smuggling trails extending across several states. Tennessee experienced a similar spike in clandestine cigarette establishments near borders post-tax increases in the early 2000s, echoing vintage "beer flat" markets but now with cigarettes.

A deeper dive shows complexity. A January 2018 report by Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health outlined implications for states, including Indiana, elevating cigarette taxes by 50 cents or more. After Indiana’s hike in 2007, revenue surged 43% in a year, indicating net gains even amid smuggling concerns.

Enforcement Overhaul: What’s New?

On July 1, Indiana's cigarette tax more than doubles, fueling rigorous enforcement measures:

  • Cracking down on bulk out-of-state purchases, converting heavy-load stashers to felons.Image 2

  • Amplified task forces—involving Excise and state police—inspecting shipments at toll booths and warehouses.

  • Surprise audits of wholesalers and retailers to catch counterfeit tax stamps.

  • Anticipated revenue impact: $290 million annually, allocated to public health initiatives.

Cross-Border Temptations & Enforcement Challenges

Vigilance remains crucial, given Indiana's proximity to low-tax regions like Kentucky. The Tax Foundation’s study placed Indiana among the top 10 states susceptible to cigarette smuggling drifts post-tax elevations, owing to prevalent "border hopping" and informal market sales.

Ohio’s extensive highway network and low cigarette taxes add to the vigilance list. A 2024 Mackinac Center survey projected up to 12% of Indiana’s cigarette consumption may stem from out-of-state purchases in the hike’s inaugural year.

State Playbooks: Navigating Illinois & New York

Illinois:

  • Illinois lifted tobacco taxes to 45% wholesale, escalating smuggling risks.

  • An estimated 30% of cigarettes in Illinois are sourced illicitly from neighboring states.

  • The state enforces stringent repercussions against unstamped packs—fines of $20-$25 per pack beyond nine—targeting massive shipments post-2019's tax jump ($1 per pack) spawning contraband spikes.

New York:

  • Bearing high combined taxes (state + NYC), New York witnessed over 50% smuggling rates, peaking at 61% following its latest $1-a-pack increase.

  • The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco & Firearms alongside the state’s Tax Enforcement Office execute felony trafficking statutes (Class D/E felonies for 10,000+ cigarettes).

Hoosier Smuggling Legacy

Bootlegging is entwined with Indiana’s financial lineage. During Prohibition, Southern Indiana counties—Lawrence, Dubois, Orange—were moonshine powerhouses, utilizing “Whiskey Roads” under the cover of night.

The tactic remains surprisingly uniform—substitute packs for pints, identify loopholes, leverage geography, and evade detection.

Former Indiana Excise officer John Halverson observed, “Back then, it was stills in barns. Now it’s cartons in car trunks.”

Health Triumph or Policy Gamble?

Some view the smuggling rise as less of a policy miss and more of a public health win. Despite some circumvented taxes, elevated prices lead to significant smoking reductions, especially among youth and low-income groups.

Mike Seilback, the National Assistant Vice President for Advocacy at the American Lung Association, commented toThe Indiana Capital Chronicle:

“Elevated tobacco prices are the most effective smoking deterrent. We foresee numerous Hoosiers quitting and youths abstaining from starting.”Image 3

Even with smuggling rates reaching 10-30%, studies illustrate potential net revenue increases post-tax hikes if enforcement sustains. Indiana’s 2007 hike—yielding a 41% reduction in sales but a 43% climb in revenue—mirrors this absorption.

Evaluating Strategy's Viability

Indiana wagers the strategy will succeed beyond revenue. Can it harmonize deterring smuggling with effective enforcement? Will smaller communities brace for impacts? And can contemporary smugglers—today’s moonshine covert operators in modern vehicles—remain elusive?

Time must unveil answers, but presently, the Prohibition spirit resonates along the Midwest’s rural byways. The stakes are elevated, vehicles accelerated, and tax stamps sophisticated—but the enduring game of bootlegging? As Hoosier as it gets.

Share this article...
Facebook
Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Pocket Reddit Email

Want tax & accounting tips and insights?

Sign up for our newsletter.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .